TrueCar CEO Scott Painter on The Curve, Cyber Monday and the year since his return

TrueCar’s founder and CEO talks about bringing back The Curve and the Savings Certificate, where financing fits, and his plan to turn TrueCar into an automotive AI platform.
Thirteen months after returning to the company he founded, Scott Painter says TrueCar is profitable again. He is now taking it back to what first set it apart: showing car buyers what other people actually paid.
“The Curve is what made TrueCar unique,” Painter told Auto Dealer News. “Being able to know what a good deal is is essential to being able to get a good deal.”
This week TrueCar reintroduced The Curve, its price-distribution bell curve, along with the Savings Certificate, a dealer-backed offer that shoppers can now store as a QR code in Apple or Google Wallet. Painter spoke with us about why those tools are back, what they mean for dealers, and where the company is headed in 2027.
Why The Curve is back
The Curve plots what buyers paid for the same make, model, and trim over the last 30, 60 or 90 days, both locally and nationally. Painter said most shoppers aren’t chasing the lowest price on the chart. They just don’t want to pay more than the next person.
He said that matters most for buyers who feel intimidated at the dealership, including first-time buyers, older shoppers, and people with credit challenges. “This levels the playing field,” he said. “You don’t need to be a rocket scientist to understand a bell curve.”
Painter gave an example. A car has a $52,000 MSRP, others paid $49,000 on average, and a dealer offers $46,000. “I’ve got 3,000 great reasons to go ahead and buy that car,” he said.
He also said that data is something a general AI assistant can’t supply. TrueCar draws on registration data, dealer data, and millions of other transaction data points. “TrueCar is a data company at heart,” he said.
A private offer, not an advertisement
The Savings Certificate turns a dealer’s price into a private offer to an eligible TrueCar user. Painter described it as “a legally binding contract to deliver the car for that price.”
Painter said that distinction should matter to dealers worried about AI tools pitting them against each other on price. “When a customer gets a price from TrueCar, that is a single private offer from one dealer to one customer on one car,” he said. “The dealer is not boiling the ocean to bring prices down.”
Adding the certificate to Apple and Google Wallet reflects how people shop now, he said. “We all live on our cell phones today,” Painter said. Because buying a car still ends with a physical delivery, the QR code is “the easiest way to convey all that information and that contract between the dealer and the customer.”
Financing and the “belly of the market”
With front-end margins down from their pandemic highs, Painter pointed to financing as central to the deal. He noted that 94% of consumers finance their vehicles. Buyers with a FICO score of 720 or higher often lease, while those in the 640–720 range, “what we call the belly of the market,” usually take out a loan.
Affordability is the main concern right now, he said, with higher interest rates and tariff pressure weighing on buyers. He broke potential savings into three layers:
- OEM incentives, typically 7–10% of the vehicle price
- Competitive dealer pricing through TrueCar, another 7–10%
- Affinity member discounts for Sam’s Club members, PenFed customers and credit union members, worth hundreds and sometimes thousands of dollars
“In total, you can save somewhere between 20 and 25% off of MSRP on your next new car,” Painter said.
Treat year-end like a “super month”
For dealers heading into Black Friday, Cyber Monday and year-end clearance, Painter said the usual advice about shopping at month-end applies to the whole season. “Just think of the end of the year as a super month,” he said.
He said cars are sitting on lots longer than ever, which has driven heavy discounting, and the overall market is slow. His advice to dealers is to reach out to shoppers now and focus on what they care about. “They’re focused on that monthly payment and they’re focused on getting a good deal,” he said.
Rescue, repair, reinvent
Painter said his proudest accomplishment since returning is getting the company profitable and staying there. TrueCar was losing roughly $2.5 million to $3 million a month when his team took over.
“We did the hard things. I call it hugging the cactus,” he said. The company cut headcount from almost 400 to just over 200 and exited three or four business lines to refocus on price transparency.
He described the turnaround in three phases:
- Rescue: stop the losses, which TrueCar did in the first quarter and has sustained.
- Repair: rebuild the core product, including The Curve and the Savings Certificate. Painter said the company is “mid river” and needs another three to six months.
- Reinvent: move from a website to an app and from shopping to “shopping, buying, and owning.” The goal is that a TrueCar customer arrives at the dealership “more like an order than a lead.”
A new-car “department store”
TrueCar has also brought back its option-logic configurator. Painter said it separates TrueCar from the other major marketplaces: Cars.com, Autotrader, CarGurus and Carfax. About 80% of TrueCar shoppers want a new car, he said, while about 80% of shoppers on the other sites are looking for used.
Shoppers can build any new car and see the price. Painter compared it to shopping “in the right aisle at the grocery store.” He noted that four-wheel drive, something you don’t need in a market like Los Angeles, can be an $8,000 option in some markets, and that a Highlander can run from the high $30,000s to more than $70,000 depending on the package. The average consumer can feel overwhelmed and intimidated by these options. TrueCar can help cut through that noise.
He said his family covers both ends of the market. “I’ve got a 16-year-old daughter who thinks she knows everything and knows nothing about cars, and then I’ve got an 85-year-old mother who just doesn’t know anything about cars,” he said. “Both of them find that going to TrueCar is really helpful.”
“Computer, I need a car”
Painter’s long-term goal is still the “Captain Kirk” vision he described to Dealer Agent News in March: a buyer says “I need a car” and the system handles the rest. Over the next three to six months, he said, TrueCar will move from search toward conversation. “TrueCar will be automotive AI,” he said.
He added that TrueCar’s pricing data sits in a “walled garden” that outside AI tools can’t scrape. In three to five years, he expects instant car loans and digital trade-in appraisals based on 90 seconds of walking around the vehicle. “Nobody’s going to overpay or underpay for a car,” he said. “There isn’t a technology blocker. It is really just a standard practices blocker.”
A “kinder, gentler TrueCar” for dealers
Asked how dealers can get the most from TrueCar, Painter pointed to new-car introductions that are as close to orders as possible. He said the pricing question itself has changed since the company’s early days.
“We’re not just asking where’s the breaking point,” he said. “We’re saying what is the way to maximize, optimize margin, and unlock velocity.”
He called this version of the company a “kinder, gentler TrueCar,” focused on helping dealers “retain margin and not give money away that they don’t have to.” In the dealership marketplace, he said, there is always a dealer willing to sell at a fair price, and “most dealers and most consumers do find that they can meet in that middle.”
What’s next
Painter said 2027 will focus on new revenue streams beyond the car itself: the trade-in, financing, and insurance.
“We want to help our dealers capture all those different revenue streams because those represent the non-commoditized parts of the transaction,” he said. After that, he said, “2028 for us is going to be about scale.”
About TrueCar: TrueCar is a digital automotive platform founded in 2005 by Scott Painter. It works through a nationwide network of TrueCar Certified Dealers and powers auto-buying programs for more than 250 brands, including Sam’s Club, AAA, and more than 80 credit unions.



